Rubric

Writing a Claim
Writing a Claim
Criteria Ratings Pts
Claim
A conclusion that answers the original question.
threshold: pts
3 pts Meeting Mastery Makes an accurate and complete claim.
2 pts Approaching Mastery Makes an accurate, but incomplete claim.
1 pts Beginning Mastery Makes an inaccurate Claim
0 pts No Marks Incomplete - Does NOT make a claim.
pts
3 pts
--
Evidence
The data needs to be appropriate and sufficient to support the claim.
threshold: pts
2 pts Meeting Mastery Provides appropriate and sufficient evidence to support the claim.
1 pts Approaching Mastery Provides appropriate, but insufficient evidence. May include some inappropriate evidence.
0 pts No Marks Incomplete - Does NOT provide evidence.
pts
2 pts
--
Reasoning
A justification that links the claim to the evidence. It shows why the data counts as evidence by using appropriate scientific principles.
threshold: pts
3 pts Meeting Mastery Provides accurate and complete reasoning that links evidence to the claim.
2 pts Approaching Mastery Provides reasoning that links claims to evidence. Repeats evidence.
1 pts Beginning Mastery The reasoning is not appropriate or does not link the claim to the evidence.
0 pts No Marks Incomplete - Does NOT include reasoning.
pts
3 pts
--